I didn't see any of the movies that you mentioned. But, his demeanor and tongue-in-cheek humor was sooo Andy. The more I watched, the more I fell in love with his character.
My son loved him in the Spiderman role too. He said he's a much better Spiderman than Tobey, and I agree. At first, I was trying to be on Tobey's side, but after the movie I just gave it up.
So much reminded me of Andy, the way he walked, and everything. It was surreal.
Hmmm...now I want to see Spiderman. Even if I don't go to the theatre to see it, I am sure I will watch it when it comes to on DVD. Will compare notes then, haha.