I did not follow boxing much when it turned into pay per view only and missed Calzaghe. Great fighter no doubt. Going to have to watch his great fights. and make a better judgement on him. Was he like Stevie Collins who kind of got Benn and Eubank at the end of their careers? I dont think so Roy Jones and BHop were still formidable and both had defense.
Calzaghe was blessed with great speed, could take a shot and could change styles mid-fight depending on how the fight was unfolding. Hopkins was still very much a live and formidable opponent and that was actually a very tough fight. Joe got dropped in the first round, although he wasn't seriously hurt and Hopkins really tested him. I thought Joe deservedly won the fight through sheer work rate (nobody else has landed as many punches on Hopkins in his career). Hopkins is a great, great fighter though - an all-time great without doubt.
Jones for me, was pretty shot when he fought Joe and as such it was difficult for me to put too much name value on beating Roy. He was a shell of a great fighter when took on Joe. BUT.... Joe's speed would have always caused problems for Roy... it's difficult to say who would have won in their prime, but I seriously doubt Roy would have taken that fight in his prime either.
Calzaghe was accused by some as being a slapper... Jones said it before the fight but afterwards acknowledged he was a damn hard slapper!
Joe had a lot of problems with his hands throughout his career and punched harder when he was younger... He dropped granite chinned Eubank when they fought.
Of all the British and Island Super Middles, he was without doubt the best in my mind. He absolutely ruined an unbeaten Jeff Lacy who was hailed as the next big thing at the time (Lacy was never the same again) and beat a prime unbeaten Kessler. I saw him a few times live, including the Kessler fight in front of over 50,000 people at the Millenium Stadium in Cardiff.